18 November 2025 Tuesday

Migrate Hemisphere Mixing To Python Grade MPL

Brian: 5.5/10 Would be good to note the settings that were actually used, not just the fact that you didn't have to change them. Not clear how the uncertainty on the peak positions were determined "incomplete will flesh out more" Would be good to see a discussion of uncertainties… which uncertainties were included in the data analysis? Not obvious from the notebook.

Sam : 7/10

• No discussion of experimental setup (eg: settings that were actually used)
• No discussion of converting velocity bins to energy bins.
• Nice description of fitting for the peak positions. NO discussion of fit quality though… are the fits good ? does it matter ?

• Would be good to see a discussion of uncertainties… which uncertainties were included in the "data analysis approach 2"… Seems like only the position of the peaks.

• A lot of worked out results lack units.